The Best Sandwiches in New York City

A sandwich is never just a sandwich in New York. It’s a meal that tells a story, a portable piece of history you can hold in your hands. It’s the hand-carved pastrami at a Jewish deli that’s been here for a century, the Italian hero piled high with cold cuts in a Brooklyn salumeria, and the foil-wrapped chopped cheese from a Harlem bodega that fuels the neighborhood. These aren't just lists of ingredients between bread; they are pillars of the city's food culture.

We’re not interested in sad desk lunches. We’re talking about destination sandwiches, the kind you cross boroughs to eat. From the old-world delis of the Lower East Side to the new-school sandwich shops redefining the form, this is our guide to the city's best.

The Classics

These are the sandwiches that built New York's reputation. They are institutions, standard-bearers, and still the ones to beat.

Katz's Delicatessen

Lower East Side · 205 E Houston St · $$$ WebsiteMap

There is no conversation about New York sandwiches that doesn't start here. The pastrami on rye at Katz's is a rite of passage. The meat is cured for weeks, smoked, boiled, and then hand-carved into a pile so generous it feels like a challenge. It’s tender, peppery, and melts in your mouth. Yes, it’s a tourist magnet, and yes, it’s expensive, but it remains the undisputed champion. Just don't lose your ticket.

Go for: The pastrami on rye is non-negotiable for a first-timer. The Reuben, with melted Swiss, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing, is also world-class. Know before you go: The counter service is part of the experience. Grab a ticket when you walk in, tell the carver what you want, and tip them a dollar. The deli reopened its long-hidden "Ludlow Room" in 2026, adding more seating for the first time in decades.

Faicco's Italian Specialties

Greenwich Village · 260 Bleecker St · $$ WebsiteMap

This century-old Italian butcher shop and deli is a Greenwich Village holdout, a place where the mozzarella is made fresh and the heroes are built to last. The star is the Italian Special: a formidable combination of prosciutto, capicola, soppressata, and house-made mozzarella, topped with roasted peppers. It’s a dense, delicious monster of a sandwich that respects the quality of its ingredients above all else.

Go for: The Italian Special. Know before you go: It’s primarily a takeaway spot with very limited space. Cash is preferred.

Blue Sky Deli (Hajji's)

East Harlem · 2135 1st Ave · $ WebsiteMap

For the uninitiated, the chopped cheese is New York's unofficial sandwich. And Blue Sky Deli, better known as Hajji's, is its spiritual home, often credited with its invention. Ground beef gets chopped up on the griddle with onions, covered in American cheese until it melts into a glorious mess, and then packed into a hero roll with lettuce, tomato, mayo, and ketchup. It's a perfect meal for a few bucks and a true taste of uptown.

Go for: The classic chopped cheese, "the Hajji way". Know before you go: This is a no-frills bodega, not a restaurant. Order at the counter and be ready with your cash.

Defonte's Sandwich Shop

Red Hook · 379 Columbia St · $$ WebsiteMap

A Red Hook landmark since 1922, Defonte's serves heroes that are a meal in themselves. The bread is crusty, the portions are massive, and the combinations are timeless. The menu is a mix of hot and cold heroes, but the Nicky Special is the thing to get: ham, capicola, salami, fried eggplant, provolone, and hot salad. It’s a Brooklyn classic that has rightfully earned its place in the city's sandwich pantheon. They also make an excellent vegetarian Valentino Special with fried eggplant.

Go for: The Nicky Special or the Hot Roast Beef with fresh mozzarella and fried eggplant. Know before you go: It’s a bit of a trek to Red Hook, but worth the journey. They have a smaller location in Gramercy, but the original is the real deal.

The Italian Heroes

Beyond the basics, these spots specialize in the fine art of the Italian hero, where quality cold cuts, fresh mozzarella, and great bread create something special.

Lioni Italian Heroes

Bensonhurst · 7803 15th Ave · $$ WebsiteMap

With a menu boasting over 150 sandwiches, Lioni's can be intimidating. But this Bensonhurst institution is a master of the form, renowned for its creamy, house-made mozzarella. The heroes are named after famous Italian Americans, and ordering by number is the pro move. Try the #2, the Dean Martin (prosciutto, fresh mozzarella), or dive deep into the encyclopedic menu. It’s a destination deli that’s pure Brooklyn.

Go for: Anything featuring the fresh mozzarella. The #1 Frank Sinatra (salami, fresh mozzarella) is a great place to start. Know before you go: Study the menu online before you go to avoid holding up the line.

Regina's Grocery

Lower East Side · 27 Orchard St · $$ WebsiteMap

Regina's brings a touch of Bensonhurst style to the Lower East Side, serving up heroes inspired by family recipes in a shop that feels like a neighborhood kitchen. Sandwiches are named for family members and packed with high-quality ingredients. The Uncle Jimmy, with prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, hot soppressata, arugula, and balsamic, is a perfectly balanced classic. The shop has expanded, with several locations now open, including a new spot in the East Village as of 2026.

Go for: The Uncle Jimmy or the Roman, a chicken cutlet hero with a vodka-sauce twist. Know before you go: The original Orchard Street location is small and can get crowded during the lunch rush.

Alidoro

SoHo · 105 Sullivan St · $$ WebsiteMap

Alidoro elevates the Italian sandwich with an obsessive focus on sourcing the absolute best ingredients. These are not oversized, sloppy heroes; they are meticulously constructed panini where every element sings. The bread is perfect, the prosciutto is sliced paper-thin, and house-made spreads like truffle cream or mushroom paste add another dimension. The namesake "Alidoro" sandwich with prosciutto, hot peppers, and mushroom paste is a masterclass in flavor. The brand has seen significant expansion in 2026, opening new locations from the Flatiron District to the Empire State Building.

Go for: The Pinocchio, with prosciutto, soppressata, fresh mozzarella, and arugula. Know before you go: Don't ask for modifications. These sandwiches are designed to be enjoyed as is.

More Than a Deli

These are the new-school spots and specialty shops making some of the most exciting sandwiches in the city right now.

Court Street Grocers

Carroll Gardens · 485 Court St · $$ WebsiteMap

With several locations, Court Street Grocers has built a loyal following for its thoughtfully sourced and cleverly constructed sandwiches. They nail the classics but also excel at original creations. The Vegitalian, with roasted butternut squash, and a broccoli Reuben show that vegetarian sandwiches can be just as compelling as their meaty counterparts. For a true indulgence, the Cubano is one of the city's best.

Go for: The Italian Combo for a perfect classic, or the Vegitalian for something different. Know before you go: The original Carroll Gardens location has the most charm, but the sandwiches are consistently great everywhere.

Superiority Burger

East Village · 119 Avenue A · $$ WebsiteMap

While known for its veggie burger (one of the best burgers in NYC), this vegetarian diner from a former pastry chef also makes one of the city's most craveable sandwiches. The Collard Greens sandwich features slow-braised greens and melted cheddar cheese on incredible, house-baked sesame seed focaccia. It's a warm, comforting, and utterly unique creation that you'll be thinking about long after you finish it.

Go for: The Collard Greens Sandwich. Know before you go: The space is small and often packed. Go at an off-hour if you want to snag a seat.

Margon

Midtown · 136 W 46th St · $ Map

Hidden in the chaos of Times Square, Margon is a slice of old-school New York that has been serving Cuban and Dominican food for over 50 years. It's a lifeline for anyone seeking a great, affordable lunch in an area full of tourist traps. Their Cuban sandwich is the real deal: roasted pork, ham, swiss, pickles, and a garlicky mojo sauce pressed until crisp and hot. It’s a perfect, no-nonsense classic.

Go for: The Cuban Sandwich. A side of rice and beans is practically mandatory. Know before you go: It’s a small, busy lunch counter. Be prepared to eat standing or take it to go.

Bánh Mì Anh Em

East Village · 90 E 7th St · $ WebsiteMap

This tiny East Village spot bakes its own baguettes, and it makes all the difference. The bread is light and crackly, the perfect vessel for the colorful fillings. Their O.G. Bánh Mì is a standout, layered with beef, ham, head cheese, house-made pâté, and pork floss, then loaded with cilantro, chiles, and pickled vegetables. It’s a complex, flavor-packed sandwich that hits all the right notes.

Go for: The O.G. Bánh Mì. Know before you go: Expect a line out the door at peak times. It's worth the wait.

---

The Shout NY Take

A great sandwich is a perfect food. It’s self-contained, endlessly adaptable, and speaks volumes about the neighborhood it comes from. Whether it's a hundred-year-old recipe or a modern vegetarian creation, the best sandwiches in New York are more than just lunch. They’re part of the city's fabric, and they’re essential. Use this guide to find your own favorites, from the iconic to the unexpected. You will not be disappointed.