NY Pizza Suprema.

In 2 Shout NY guides.

1. Food + Drink

   The Best Pizza Slices in New York City

   Across from Penn Station and Madison Square Garden, in a zip code full of sad food, Suprema is a family run counter that has been doing this for almost 50 years.

   Go for: a plain slice, then a specialty slice from the case.

2. Food + Drink

   Where to Eat Near Madison Square Garden

   The family has run this counter across from the Garden since 1964, and it is the one slice shop in the Penn Station orbit that serious pizza people will defend out loud.

   Go for: the upside-down slice and a plain.