McSorley's Old Ale House.
In 2 Shout NY guides.
Nightlife
The Best Dive Bars in New York City
Open since 1854, which makes it the oldest Irish saloon in the city and the only bar where the menu is a binary choice: light or dark.
Go for: a round of darks and a plate of cheese, crackers and raw onion.
City
The East Village Guide: Where to Eat, Drink and Go Out in 2026
Opened in 1854 and still pouring two drinks: light ale and dark ale, served in pairs of small mugs.
Go for: Two lights, two darks, a plate of cheese and onions.